Suz and I have made a concerted effort to catch up with our comicbook TV viewing lately, particularly since the new season is now underway and we don't want to end up a year behind. That way lay spoilers and ruined punchlines. Being a fair bit behind and steamrollering through makes one-or-two episode reviews too much of a chore, so I've decided to give each series a quick overview.
Supergirl built on a promising and very entertaining first season with a second season that set out a clearer idea of what the show was. Although the legacy of Krypton and Kara's family was still part of the series' story, the second season had a wider focus on DC aliens and various character relationships.
Season three continues on that line, with the strongest elements remaining the core of the series. The series continues to be a boldly female-centred show, with the mix of heroes being somewhat skewed female in numbers but considerably so in terms of focus. It's no accident that this is a proudly emotional series, dealing with character relationships as much as alien infiltration and with emotional fallout as much as superpowered fisticuffs.
I surprised myself when I was thinking about the various main characters in this increasingly busy ensemble, in that the strongest character for me is Alex. Chyler Leigh has grown into her character brilliantly, giving a mature performance as a character physically tough and ballsy, yet also emotionally vulnerable and open. There's a strong line of development for Alex, as she deals with her newly accepted sexuality; her relationship with Maggie is her primary storyline in the first part of the season, but their different goals in life force them apart. I admire the writing for her character, in that she gets to act out certain destructive traits usually reserved for men: using alcohol and casual sex as a way to deal with heartbreak, but she also has the opportunity to move past these. (A quick one-nighter with Sara Lance in the "Earth-X" crossover sure helps, and got the shippers jumping about.)
However, Alex also gets to explore traditionally female traits, in particular her desire to become a mother (the very thing that causes the rift between her and Maggie). It's a strong character treatment that doesn't saddle her with just being "the butch one" or "the lesbian," but allows her a range of character elements and the chance to be a strong, flawed, interesting character. Over the course of the season, she gets to develop her emotional skills in a way that helps other characters as well.
Shen it comes to Supergirl herself, there's actually a fair bit of negative development, which is just as interesting. The problem with Kryptonian superheroes is that they're often just too good to be engaging, but there's a fine balance somewhere between Superman as the Boy Scout of the universe and Superman cracking necks on the big screen. I like how they're make Kara an incredible hero but at the same time seriously flawed as a person. She's frequently hypocritical and often selfish, which makes her all the more human. Kara goes through a lot of difficult emotional stuff this season, with huge developments that should be tremendously positive knocking her for six. Mon-El comes back through a wonderfully contrived time travel narrative designed to introduce the Legion of Superheroes to the CW multiverse. Chris Wood is brilliant as the older, more mature, more responsible version of Mon-El, imbuing him with some real gravitas even when he's wearing that utterly silly inverse Superman costume. On the other end of things, Kara discovers Argo City, the sole remaining part of Krypton (unless Kandor shows up in a jar someday), tempted to give up her life on Earth and settle there with her family. It's tempting to say that the Argo period is over too quickly, given that this is such a huge deal for Kara, but frankly it's not a terribly interesting place and we're just eager for her to get back to Earth. (BTW, has anyone bothered to tell Superman about this?)
Supergirl is a real ensemble show, and everyone gets some decent exploration. Even James, who still doesn't convince as Guardian, is used much better this season. His relationship with Lena Luthor didn't convince me immediately, but it was well-written and performed, but his best moments were in episode 19, "The Fanatical," which sees him contemplate shedding his mask and facing the reality of being a black vigilante in the States. Obviously, this is material featured far more heavily in Black Lightning and Luke Cage, but it's important to appear here. People protesting that not every black character in TV should have to deal with a racist storyline miss the point: that every black person in America (and pretty much, the West), has to deal with racism during their lives. Obviously, they're not generally acting as super-vigilantes, but it's an effective way to illustrate how people's attitudes change when confronted with someone of a different race.
Without going into too much depth on every regular character, Lena walks a fine line between friend and confidante of Kara and potential villain, and no way do I believe she doesn't know Kara's Supergirl. Winn has his best season yet, bringing the best moments of sidekick comic relief through sheer enthusiasm, while showing real believable human vulnerability as the one vaguely normal person surrounded by aliens and soldiers. I'm stoked to see how he gets on as a member of the Legion, because Jeremy Jordan has been quietly brilliant this year. I'm still annoyed, though, that he and Cisco never got to meet and geek out together.
David Harewood has shown what a fine actor he can be when given some decent material. Given that Kara, Mon-El and J'onn have all lost their peoples, it's J'onn who really displays the aching loss of it. Reuniting him with his father, Myrrn, is a brilliant move, and is so much stronger emotionally than seeing Supergirl reunite with her mother on Argo. Thanks to a dignified and moving performance by Carl Lumbly, what could have been a mawkish storyline is incredibly affecting, as Myrrn suffers the Martian equivalent of Alzheimer's. Even with all the over-the-top sci-fi trappings, it's profoundly moving.
Unfortunately, the overarching storyline, of Reign and her sisters threatening to devastate the Earth, just isn't strong enough to sustain the season. Odette Annable is perfectly good in the role, and is very sympathetic and likable as Reign's alter ego, Sam, but Reign is such a dull, one note character it's hard to stay interested in her. The other two, Pestilence and what's-her-name, are even less interesting, and frankly it's a relief they don't last long. I understand it's important to have a villain capable of besting Supergirl and also to show the difference between the human side and the Worldkiller, but it ends up as a season of a villain with no personality.
Which is the only real negative in what's been a very strong season, for a series that has always had its strengths in the emotional storylines. Some more quick praise: for young Emma Tremblay as Sam's daughter Ruby, who is frankly quite brilliant; for the truly stunning Amy Jackson as Imra, and how fun is it to have Saturn Girl in the series; and lovely Jesse Rath as Brainiac-5, the 31st century android who, wonderfully, is going to stick around as Winn's replacement. (I still don't quite understand the Brainiac family tree, especially with the various continuities in play, especially as we've already met Brainiac-12, but nevermind. In the comics Brainy and Supergirl have a thing, which could be fun to see onscreen, if supremely unlikely.)
One of the more consistent, arguably tiresome, threads of Supergirl is Kara's absolute refusal to kill, even when her enemies are threatening to annihilate the entire population of the Earth. It's one of those arguments that could go on forever, of course, although I'd say that the devastation caused when she finally kills Reign is more an argument that they should have killed her sooner, rather than when she was at full destructive power. In any case, due to a nifty bit of time travel that would make Christopher Reeve proud, Kara creates a much more pleasant outcome, but as we know, that sort of thing has consequences.
Supergirl built on a promising and very entertaining first season with a second season that set out a clearer idea of what the show was. Although the legacy of Krypton and Kara's family was still part of the series' story, the second season had a wider focus on DC aliens and various character relationships.
Season three continues on that line, with the strongest elements remaining the core of the series. The series continues to be a boldly female-centred show, with the mix of heroes being somewhat skewed female in numbers but considerably so in terms of focus. It's no accident that this is a proudly emotional series, dealing with character relationships as much as alien infiltration and with emotional fallout as much as superpowered fisticuffs.
I surprised myself when I was thinking about the various main characters in this increasingly busy ensemble, in that the strongest character for me is Alex. Chyler Leigh has grown into her character brilliantly, giving a mature performance as a character physically tough and ballsy, yet also emotionally vulnerable and open. There's a strong line of development for Alex, as she deals with her newly accepted sexuality; her relationship with Maggie is her primary storyline in the first part of the season, but their different goals in life force them apart. I admire the writing for her character, in that she gets to act out certain destructive traits usually reserved for men: using alcohol and casual sex as a way to deal with heartbreak, but she also has the opportunity to move past these. (A quick one-nighter with Sara Lance in the "Earth-X" crossover sure helps, and got the shippers jumping about.)
However, Alex also gets to explore traditionally female traits, in particular her desire to become a mother (the very thing that causes the rift between her and Maggie). It's a strong character treatment that doesn't saddle her with just being "the butch one" or "the lesbian," but allows her a range of character elements and the chance to be a strong, flawed, interesting character. Over the course of the season, she gets to develop her emotional skills in a way that helps other characters as well.
Shen it comes to Supergirl herself, there's actually a fair bit of negative development, which is just as interesting. The problem with Kryptonian superheroes is that they're often just too good to be engaging, but there's a fine balance somewhere between Superman as the Boy Scout of the universe and Superman cracking necks on the big screen. I like how they're make Kara an incredible hero but at the same time seriously flawed as a person. She's frequently hypocritical and often selfish, which makes her all the more human. Kara goes through a lot of difficult emotional stuff this season, with huge developments that should be tremendously positive knocking her for six. Mon-El comes back through a wonderfully contrived time travel narrative designed to introduce the Legion of Superheroes to the CW multiverse. Chris Wood is brilliant as the older, more mature, more responsible version of Mon-El, imbuing him with some real gravitas even when he's wearing that utterly silly inverse Superman costume. On the other end of things, Kara discovers Argo City, the sole remaining part of Krypton (unless Kandor shows up in a jar someday), tempted to give up her life on Earth and settle there with her family. It's tempting to say that the Argo period is over too quickly, given that this is such a huge deal for Kara, but frankly it's not a terribly interesting place and we're just eager for her to get back to Earth. (BTW, has anyone bothered to tell Superman about this?)
Supergirl is a real ensemble show, and everyone gets some decent exploration. Even James, who still doesn't convince as Guardian, is used much better this season. His relationship with Lena Luthor didn't convince me immediately, but it was well-written and performed, but his best moments were in episode 19, "The Fanatical," which sees him contemplate shedding his mask and facing the reality of being a black vigilante in the States. Obviously, this is material featured far more heavily in Black Lightning and Luke Cage, but it's important to appear here. People protesting that not every black character in TV should have to deal with a racist storyline miss the point: that every black person in America (and pretty much, the West), has to deal with racism during their lives. Obviously, they're not generally acting as super-vigilantes, but it's an effective way to illustrate how people's attitudes change when confronted with someone of a different race.
Without going into too much depth on every regular character, Lena walks a fine line between friend and confidante of Kara and potential villain, and no way do I believe she doesn't know Kara's Supergirl. Winn has his best season yet, bringing the best moments of sidekick comic relief through sheer enthusiasm, while showing real believable human vulnerability as the one vaguely normal person surrounded by aliens and soldiers. I'm stoked to see how he gets on as a member of the Legion, because Jeremy Jordan has been quietly brilliant this year. I'm still annoyed, though, that he and Cisco never got to meet and geek out together.
David Harewood has shown what a fine actor he can be when given some decent material. Given that Kara, Mon-El and J'onn have all lost their peoples, it's J'onn who really displays the aching loss of it. Reuniting him with his father, Myrrn, is a brilliant move, and is so much stronger emotionally than seeing Supergirl reunite with her mother on Argo. Thanks to a dignified and moving performance by Carl Lumbly, what could have been a mawkish storyline is incredibly affecting, as Myrrn suffers the Martian equivalent of Alzheimer's. Even with all the over-the-top sci-fi trappings, it's profoundly moving.
Unfortunately, the overarching storyline, of Reign and her sisters threatening to devastate the Earth, just isn't strong enough to sustain the season. Odette Annable is perfectly good in the role, and is very sympathetic and likable as Reign's alter ego, Sam, but Reign is such a dull, one note character it's hard to stay interested in her. The other two, Pestilence and what's-her-name, are even less interesting, and frankly it's a relief they don't last long. I understand it's important to have a villain capable of besting Supergirl and also to show the difference between the human side and the Worldkiller, but it ends up as a season of a villain with no personality.
Which is the only real negative in what's been a very strong season, for a series that has always had its strengths in the emotional storylines. Some more quick praise: for young Emma Tremblay as Sam's daughter Ruby, who is frankly quite brilliant; for the truly stunning Amy Jackson as Imra, and how fun is it to have Saturn Girl in the series; and lovely Jesse Rath as Brainiac-5, the 31st century android who, wonderfully, is going to stick around as Winn's replacement. (I still don't quite understand the Brainiac family tree, especially with the various continuities in play, especially as we've already met Brainiac-12, but nevermind. In the comics Brainy and Supergirl have a thing, which could be fun to see onscreen, if supremely unlikely.)
One of the more consistent, arguably tiresome, threads of Supergirl is Kara's absolute refusal to kill, even when her enemies are threatening to annihilate the entire population of the Earth. It's one of those arguments that could go on forever, of course, although I'd say that the devastation caused when she finally kills Reign is more an argument that they should have killed her sooner, rather than when she was at full destructive power. In any case, due to a nifty bit of time travel that would make Christopher Reeve proud, Kara creates a much more pleasant outcome, but as we know, that sort of thing has consequences.
No comments:
Post a Comment